ICA tax liability in hydrocarbon exploration and exploitation activities under the royalty regime in the municipality of Puerto Boyacá

Table of contents


We want to provide you with up-to-date and valuable information, that's why we created Amézquita Tax Trends, where you'll find news and expert analysis on the changes in the tax landscape and  latest tax trends.


ICA tax liability in hydrocarbon exploration and exploitation activities under the royalty regime in the municipality of Puerto Boyacá.

The Fourth Section of the Council of State confirmed that the income obtained from the exploitation and exploration of hydrocarbons in the municipality of Puerto Boyacá is subject to the Industry and Commerce Tax (ICA), in accordance with the provisions of Law 14 of 1983.

The ruling reiterated that local governments have the authority to levy the Industry and Commerce Tax (ICA) on income derived from these activities, provided that the royalties received by the municipality are less than the amount that would correspond to the tax. In the case analyzed, the municipality established that the theoretical ICA amounted to $4,168,731,868, a figure that exceeded the value of the royalties received, equivalent to $1,454,919,684, by more than $2.713 billion.

The plaintiff argued that the current royalty system makes it impossible to know precisely what portion of the payments made by companies reaches each municipality, thus making the comparison required by Law 14 of 1983 impossible. However, the Council of State indicated that no evidence was provided to refute the figures presented by the municipality, and therefore these are considered valid as the basis for the challenged administrative act.

Consequently, the Court concluded that the presumption of legality of the act was not rebutted and that the income obtained by the company during 2016 was subject to ICA tax. The arguments of the appeal were unsuccessful, and therefore the judgment of the court of first instance was upheld.

 

Tax losses are not exempt from penalty control, and their improper declaration generates consequences from the period in which they originate.

The Administrative Court of Cundinamarca, Fourth Section, in a ruling dated September 18, 2025, issued in the proceedings brought by Cepsa Colombia SA against the UAE DIAN, reiterated the criteria applicable to the imposition of the penalty for inaccuracy when the taxpayer declares tax losses higher than the actual ones.

Based on Constitutional Court ruling C-910 of 2004 and Articles 647 and 647-1 of the Tax Code, the Court clarified that the punishable conduct occurs in the tax period in which the improper tax loss is declared, and not in the period in which the loss is subsequently offset. Consequently, the penalty must be calculated based on the tax return in which the disallowed or reduced loss was generated.

The Court clarified that the “theoretical tax” referred to in Article 647-1 of the Tax Code corresponds to the application of the income tax rate in effect during the period in which the loss was declared, to the value of the tax loss officially disallowed or reduced by the taxpayer. It also emphasized that this provision does not establish a separate or additional penalty, but rather regulates how to apply the penalty for inaccuracy or correction in cases of disallowance or reduction of tax losses.

Finally, the Court reiterated that the reduction or rejection of tax losses is treated, for sanctioning purposes, as the determination of a lower balance in favor, which allows the imposition of the sanction for inaccuracy without constituting a violation of the principle of non bis in idem. This ruling reinforces the doctrine that tax losses are subject to control and penalty, and must be duly supported from the period in which they originate.

 


The CTCP clarified that the obligation to consolidate financial statements falls exclusively on the parent company, and as for the combined financial statements, they are required when requested by the competent supervisory authority.

The Technical Council of Public Accounting (CTCP), in response to a query transferred by the Financial Superintendency of Colombia (SFC), specified the scope of the accounting regulations applicable to the consolidation and combination of financial statements in business groups made up of a controlling foreign company and two Colombian companies, one from the financial sector supervised by the SFC and the other from the real sector not subject to said supervision.

The CTCP recalled that the obligation to consolidate financial statements corresponds exclusively to the parent or controlling company, which in the case analyzed is the foreign entity, in accordance with article 35 of Law 222 of 1995 and IFRS 10. Consequently, the Colombian subsidiary companies are not required to consolidate with each other when there is no direct control relationship between them.

Regarding consolidated financial statements, the agency clarified that these are only required when expressly requested by the competent inspection, oversight, or control authority. In this respect, companies supervised by the SFC must comply with the specific instructions of said Superintendency, which may require consolidated information with other entities within the group for prudential supervision purposes.

Finally, the CTCP clarified that the fact that a non-supervised company has greater equity does not, in itself, impose an obligation on it to consolidate or combine financial statements with those of the supervised entity. Such an obligation would only arise if so ordered by the competent authority, such as the Superintendency of Companies.

This pronouncement reaffirms the distinction between consolidation and combination, and clearly delimits regulatory powers according to the nature and supervisory regime of each entity within the business group.


The accountant's disciplinary responsibility does not exclude or mitigate the taxpayer's legal duty to facilitate the verification of the correct determination of the tax.

The Administrative Court of Cundinamarca, Fourth Section, through a judgment of September 25, 2025, denied the claims of the lawsuit filed by Prosiso SAS against the DIAN, in which the legality of the official liquidation of the review of the sales tax corresponding to the tax year 2014 was questioned and the imposition of sanctions for inaccuracy and irregularities in the accounting.

The controversy included, among other issues, the validity of the declared deductible taxes and the penalty imposed for failing to present the official accounting records during an audit conducted by the Tax Administration. The company argued that the non-compliance was solely due to the conduct of its accountant, who neither attended the audit nor provided the required information, despite having been notified, a circumstance which, in its view, precluded attributing responsibility to the company.

In analyzing the case, the Court clarified that the obligation to provide accounting books and supporting documentation falls directly on the taxpayer company, against which the DIAN (National Tax and Customs Directorate) exercises its auditing powers, and cannot be transferred or excused based on any potential non-compliance by the accounting professional. In this regard, it clarified that the accountant's possible disciplinary or civil liability does not exclude or mitigate the taxpayer's legal duty to facilitate the verification of the correct tax calculation.

The Court concluded that Prosiso SAS failed to comply with the obligation to present the required official accounting books—journal, ledger and balance sheets, inventory and balance sheets, and minutes book—thus constituting the sanctionable act stipulated in Articles 654 and 655 of the Tax Code. Consequently, it upheld the penalty for accounting irregularities imposed by the DIAN (National Tax and Customs Directorate) in the amount of $4,866,000, as no extenuating circumstance was proven.

The ruling reaffirms that the delegation of accounting functions to third parties does not exempt the taxpayer company from its formal obligations or from the sanctioning consequences arising from its non-compliance, and consolidates a strict criterion on the responsibility in the preservation and exhibition of accounting information for tax purposes.


The CTCP specifies criteria for determining the discount rate on long-term leases under IFRS 1; do not use foreign rates for contracts in pesos.

The Technical Council of Public Accounting (CTCP), through Concept No. 2025-0263, issued a statement on the discount rate applicable to the initial and subsequent measurement of lease liabilities under IFRS 16, in a scenario of long-term contracts denominated in Colombian pesos.

The inquiry stemmed from an operating lease agreement for a warehouse, denominated in local currency (COP), with a 15-year term. The lease payment increases based on the DTF rate plus an additional margin, and the lessor is a domestic company. The central question was whether, given the length of the term, it was feasible to use local reference rates or if it was necessary to use rates from foreign markets to determine the lessee's incremental borrowing rate.

The CTCP reiterated that, according to the definition contained in Appendix A of IFRS 16, the incremental borrowing rate must reflect the term, security, economic environment, and functional currency of the contract. Consequently, it concluded that it is not appropriate to use foreign rates or rates denominated in another currency when the lease is agreed upon in Colombian pesos, as this could generate distortions arising from exchange rate risk and macroeconomic conditions that do not reflect the lessee's financial reality.

The technical body indicated that it is feasible to use local benchmark rates such as the DTF, the Central Bank's repo rate, or quotes from national financial institutions, provided these are technically adjusted to reflect: (i) the lessee's own credit risk, (ii) the long-term nature of the contract (15 years), (iii) the type and purpose of the leased asset, and (iv) the implicit guarantee or collateral conditions. In the absence of equivalent terms in the financial market, it is acceptable to employ reasonable extrapolation techniques, supported by duly documented professional judgment.

The CTCP emphasized that IFRS 16 does not prescribe a single methodology for calculating the discount rate, but it does require that this methodology be technically supported, documented, and disclosed in the financial statements. This pronouncement reinforces the need to use rates consistent with the Colombian economic environment and consolidates a relevant technical criterion for measuring long-term leases under International Financial Reporting Standards.


The Directorate of Fiscal Support (DAF) of the Ministry of Finance, through a concept filed on July 31, 2025, responded to the Finance Secretariat of San Sebastián de Mariquita (Tolima) regarding the treatment of the Industry and Commerce Tax (ICA) in operations related to exports.

The ruling stems from a query about whether merchants who sell products to an exporting company, in this case scrap metal, can benefit from the ICA exclusion, or if this benefit applies only to those who export directly.

The DAF recalled that Decree 1333 of 1986 establishes two fundamental rules:

  1. Municipalities and departments cannot tax domestically produced goods destined for export (art 259 literal b)
  2. The taxable base of the ICA excludes income from exports (art. 196, modified by Law 1819 of 2016).

Based on these provisions, the Ministry specified that:

Industrial producers who directly export their production are not subject to the ICA, as their activity is expressly excluded.

Merchants who sell to exporters are liable for the tax, as their taxable activity occurs within the domestic market. They can only exclude income if they themselves carry out the export and provide proof of the goods' actual departure using the single export form and certification from the Customs Administration.

The concept also emphasized that municipal administrations, in exercising their auditing powers, can demand additional evidence to verify that the goods have actually left the country.

The clarification precisely defines the scope of the ICA exclusion for exports: the benefit is exclusively for direct exporters of domestically produced goods. Merchants who only sell to exporters are not exempt and must comply with their tax obligations, unless they can demonstrate their own exports.


The Council of State denied the annulment and specified that the VAT exemption in the intermediation of international cruises is not automatic and requires evidentiary verification.

The Council of State, Fourth Section, through an early judgment of October 10, 2025, denied the claims of the lawsuit for annulment filed against DIAN Concept 0323 of March 23, 2018, related to the treatment in the VAT of the intermediation services provided by travel agencies resident in Colombia for the sale of tickets and packages of international cruises.

The controversy centered on determining whether the official doctrine violated subparagraph c) of article 481 of the Tax Code, by concluding that intermediation services are subject to VAT, without expressly recognizing the possibility that said services constitute an exempt export when the benefit of the service is exclusively enjoyed abroad by a foreign entity.

The Court noted that, in accordance with the territoriality principle enshrined in Article 420 of the Tax Code, the provision of services within the national territory constitutes a taxable event for VAT purposes, except for the exceptions expressly provided for by law. It further noted that subparagraph c) of Article 481 of the Tax Code provides for an exemption for exported services, provided they are used exclusively abroad and the substantive and formal requirements established in the law and its regulations are met.

However, the Council of State clarified that the challenged Opinion was limited to resolving a general query on the tax treatment applicable to intermediation in the sale of international cruises, without ruling on the specific applicability of the exemption for export of services, which it reiterated must be verified on a case-by-case basis, based on the accreditation of the exclusive use of the service abroad and compliance with the corresponding legal requirements.

The Court clarified that its previous jurisprudence has not established a general criterion on the exemption of VAT in intermediation services, but has recognized the exemption only after the evidentiary assessment in particular operations, which is why the ignorance of the judicial precedent or the illegality of the accused concept could not be asserted.

Consequently, the High Court concluded that the DIAN did not disregard the exemption provided for in article 481 of the ET, by not excluding its possible application, and denied the requested annulment.


The Council of State clarifies that Article 829 of the Tax Code does not apply to rulings on fiscal liability, as these are non-tax administrative acts.

The Council of State, Fourth Section, reiterated that in the coercive collection processes derived from rulings of fiscal responsibility that are not of a tax nature, Article 829 of the Tax Code, relating to the execution of administrative acts, is not applicable, but rather the rules provided for in the Code of Administrative Procedure and Administrative Litigation (CPACA).

The Court clarified that, pursuant to Article 100 of the CPACA, the reference to the provisions of the Tax Code regarding coercive collection is limited exclusively to procedural aspects, and does not extend to the formation of the enforceable instrument or the rules on the enforceability of the administrative acts that serve as the basis for enforcement. Consequently, the enforceability of rulings on fiscal liability must be analyzed in light of Articles 87 and 89 of the CPACA, and not Article 829 of the Tax Code.

In this specific case, the plaintiff alleged that the fiscal liability ruling was not enforceable because it was being sued before the administrative court. However, the Council of State reiterated that, in the case of non-tax administrative acts, filing a lawsuit for annulment and restoration of rights does not suspend the finality or enforceability of the act, unless one of the specific grounds for loss of enforceability provided for in Article 91 of the CPACA applies.

Thus, the Court concluded that the Comptroller General of the Republic acted within the legal framework by continuing the coercive collection process, as there was a duly executed executive title in accordance with the CPACA, and confirmed the inadmissibility of the exceptions proposed by the plaintiff.

This decision reaffirms a relevant jurisprudential criterion: the distinction between the formation of the executive title and the collection procedure, as well as the prevalence of the CPACA in non-tax coercive collection processes, even when the procedural rules of the Tax Statute are applied supplementarily.

This article has been verified by
William Andrés Oviedo Espitia,
Lawyer
Recent Publications
Categories

Search