Changes in accounting policies under IFRS: evaluation and documentation

Table of contents

Changes in accounting policies under IFRS are warranted when required by the applicable framework or when a permissible change produces more relevant and reliable information. The company must evaluate the rationale, distinguish it from an estimate update or an error, define the comparative treatment, and document its effects. The conclusion depends on the framework applicable to the entity and should be reviewed by qualified personnel.

What is considered a change in accounting policy under IFRS

An accounting policy encompasses the principles, bases, conventions, rules, and practices that an entity applies when preparing and presenting its financial statements. In practice, it determines how certain transactions are recognized, measured, and presented. Therefore, changing the name of a criterion or adding an explanation to the manual does not necessarily modify the policy if the accounting treatment applied remains the same.

The analysis should begin with the financial reporting framework applicable to the entity and the standard governing the transaction. It should also consider whether the criterion is applied consistently to similar transactions, unless the applicable framework requires or permits differentiating categories. Reviewing only the journal entry for the period, without considering the transaction and the criterion used, can lead to mistaking a policy for an estimate.

A written policy helps establish consistent criteria and communicate responsibilities. development of accounting policies under IFRS It offers a point of reference for understanding the function of that document within accounting management.

When can a change take place?

The assessment typically begins by determining whether the change is mandatory or voluntary. If it stems from a new or modified requirement that applies to the entity, its effective date and any corresponding transitional provisions must be identified. These may specify how to recognize the effects and what comparative information to present.

  • When required by the applicable framework: The entity analyzes the scope of the requirement, its application date, and the corresponding transition instructions.
  • When the entity proposes a change: It must confirm that the framework allows for that decision and support that the new policy offers more relevant and reliable information about the transactions.
  • When the facts or available information change: Before modifying the policy, it should be assessed whether what changed was an estimate and not the accounting criterion.

It is not enough for an alternative to be possible or to produce a different financial result. The decision requires explaining why the new approach better represents the nature of the operations and how it will be applied consistently. The effect on profit, equity, or key performance indicators may be part of the analysis, but it alone does not justify the change.

As an initial check, the company can ask itself three questions: What operation and policy are involved? What rule permits or requires the modification? And what evidence shows that the decision improves information or meets an applicable requirement? The answers help to define the scope of the evaluation before quantifying the effects.

Accounting policy, estimation and error: differences

The classification matters because each situation may require different treatment. The following matrix is for guidance only: the conclusion depends on the nature of the transaction, the applicable framework, and the information available in each case.

Differences between accounting policy changes, estimates, and errors

Situation What changes Hypothetical example Point of analysis
Change in accounting policy The criterion or basis applied to recognize, measure, or present a class of transactions. A company is considering switching to another permitted method for measuring a category of inventory. You must verify that the new criterion is permitted or required and, if it is voluntary, justify that it provides more relevant and reliable information.
Change in an estimate The amount calculated from data, assumptions, or uncertainties that are reviewed with new information. The company updates the estimated useful life of a piece of equipment based on new data about its use and maintenance. The accounting policy can be maintained; what is being revised is an estimate in light of updated circumstances or information.
Error from a previous period An omission or an incorrect figure related to reliable information that was available when the financial statements were prepared. A transaction supported by documentation available at closing was not recorded in the corresponding period. This is not a policy change or a new estimate. It requires a separate analysis in accordance with the rules applicable to errors.

The economic rationale for the adjustment, rather than the name given to it, is what distinguishes the situations. For example, changing a measurement method may be a policy change, while revising an assumption based on new information may be an estimate. If the case points to an error from a prior period, its correction should not be presented as a policy change. A detailed analysis of that correction is beyond the scope of this guide.

How to evaluate and document the decision

A solid technical report should enable another person to understand what was evaluated, why the decision was made, and how its effects were calculated. As a working guide, the report may include the following elements:

  1. Case delimitation: Describe the transaction, the current policy, the periods affected, and the accounting items that could change.
  2. Applicable framework and standard: Identify the relevant requirement, verify the current official text, the effective date, and the transitional provisions. This review is especially important when a standard has been amended.
  3. Justification: Explain whether the change is mandatory or voluntary. If voluntary, document why the new policy provides more relevant and reliable information, and what alternatives were considered.
  4. Accounting classification: Record why the situation corresponds to a policy change and not to an estimate or an error, based on the facts and available information.
  5. Quantification: Calculate the effects by period and by item affected where possible, including opening balances that need to be assessed. Retain the data, assumptions, and calculations that support the figures.
  6. Implementation and review: Consider adjustments to the accounting manual, closing instructions, and internal reports. Document the review and approval in accordance with the entity's governance, and verify that the financial statements and their notes reflect the analysis.

The level of detail will depend on the transaction, its effects, and applicable regulations; this list does not replace the specific requirements of each standard. The relationship between policies, records, and reports also falls within the scope of [the relevant regulations/standards]. IFRS consulting.

Retroactive application, comparisons and disclosures

Retrospective application generally involves reflecting a policy as if it had been used in previous periods. It should not be assumed that every change is applied in this way. If a standard includes transitional provisions, these guide the treatment; otherwise, the entity must determine what the applicable framework requires for the change being evaluated.

When the change is to be applied retrospectively, the analysis may affect the comparative amounts for the periods presented and the opening balances of the earliest comparative period, depending on the items involved and the required treatment. Therefore, the review is not limited to the current period's result; it must also verify the consistency between balances, comparative figures, notes, and other affected financial information.

The company must analyze what information to retain and present so that users understand the impact. Depending on applicable requirements, accounting disclosures may explain:

  • The nature of the change and the reason for the modification, or the requirement that originates it.
  • The periods and items affected, together with the amounts of the adjustments where they can be determined and where they should be disclosed.
  • The transition treatment applied and the limitations that prevented quantifying any effect, if any.

The applicable standard determines the required disclosures and the necessary level of detail. If it is not possible to calculate an effect retrospectively, the entity must document the analyses performed and follow the treatment permitted by the applicable framework; it is not sufficient to state that the calculation is complex. Final review by qualified personnel helps to verify the classification, comparative adjustments, and consistency of the notes. This guidance is general and does not constitute a conclusion for any particular entity or transaction.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is a voluntary change in accounting policy justified?

When the applicable framework allows it and the new policy produces more relevant and reliable information about transactions, the company must justify this improvement and review the implementing provisions before modifying its criteria.

Does every policy change apply retroactively?

Not necessarily. First, the transitional provisions of the rule that gives rise to the change are reviewed, and then the rules applicable to the specific situation. The treatment and comparisons depend on those provisions.

How does a policy change differ from a change in an estimate?

A policy change modifies the criteria used to account for a class of transactions. A change in estimate updates an amount or assumption based on new information or changes in circumstances, without necessarily changing the policy.

Which documents should be kept?

An analysis that identifies the transaction and the applicable standard, explains the justification and classification, includes calculations and comparative effects, and provides evidence of review and approval in accordance with the entity's governance.

What to do if previous periods cannot be recalculated?

Document which periods and effects cannot be determined, why, and what analysis was performed. Then, apply only the treatment permitted by the current regulations for the case, with review by qualified personnel.

This article has been verified by
Humberto González,
Public accountant
Recent Publications
Categories

Search