Comparison of sustainability reports in Colombia: criteria for analyzing them

Table of contents

To make a comparison of sustainability reports of Colombian companies, it is necessary to evaluate the documents under common criteria: period and scope of the report, GRI or IFRS standards used, environmental, social and governance indicators, data traceability and assurance processes.
This guide explains how to select a comparable sample, organize information into matrices, and recognize the limitations of the analysis. Its purpose is to offer an evaluation methodology, not to present the results of an original study or establish a ranking of companies.

What does a benchmark report compare?

A documentary benchmark compares the information disclosed, not solely the environmental, social, or governance performance of companies. The unit of analysis can be the report itself or the entity it covers; therefore, the scope must be defined before extracting data. In a benchmark of ESG reports in Colombia, for example, it is advisable to specify whether corporate reports, integrated documents, or other public reports will be reviewed, and to apply the same criteria to the entire sample.

A comparison of sustainability disclosures may reveal, among other things:

  • Which entities and periods does each document cover?
  • What frameworks does it mention and how does it describe their use?
  • How it presents the indicators, their units, and its methodology.
  • What information allows you to trace back to a source or section of the report.
  • If you describe review or assurance processes and what their stated scope is.

For this analysis, the maturity of ESG reports can refer to the degree to which the information is delimited, explained, and comparable or traceable. This definition must be made explicit; it is not a universal rating of an organization's sustainability. From a business perspective, the preparation of sustainability reports It requires organizing the indicators, documenting its methodology, and presenting information that can be understood and evaluated by its recipients.

Formulate an analytical question.

Before gathering documents, define what you want to answer. A focused question might be: How explicit are the scope, cited frameworks, indicator definitions, and traceability in the available reports? A specific question helps you choose the criteria and avoids expanding the analysis with variables that cannot be consistently documented.

Separate disclosure and performance

A lengthy report or the mention of a framework does not, in itself, demonstrate improved performance. The review allows us to describe what each company communicates and with what level of detail, but it does not automatically verify all the data or represent every activity within the organization. Therefore, it is more accurate to discuss information not found in the reviewed document than to conclude that a practice or management system does not exist.

How to select a comparable sample

The selection of documents determines the conclusions a benchmark can support. First, define the universe you wish to study and explain what including a Colombian company means for this analysis. You can consider criteria such as its location, its operations, or the legal entity that publishes the report, provided they are verifiable and applied consistently.

Establish rules before reviewing the results

Define in advance the sectors and types of companies you will include, the unit of analysis, and the periods you will compare. Also decide whether you will review reports from corporate groups, individual companies, or subsidiaries. If the documents cover different scopes, record that difference instead of treating them as equivalent.

The selection method must also be clear. If all documents that meet the criteria and are available are included, describe this. If a purposive or availability sample is constructed, the conclusions must be limited to the included documents; it should not be presented as representative of all Colombian companies without supporting evidence.

A selection matrix can record:

Criterion What to document Comparison rule
Universe Sectors and defined condition for including a company. Do not present a partial sample as if it covered the entire universe.
Entity and perimeter Company, group or subsidiary and scope declared in the report. Do not equate consolidated figures with figures from an individual entity without explanation.
Period Reported period, publication date, and search cutoff date. Compare equivalent periods or separate the results when they differ.
Document Title, type of report, original source and version consulted. Apply the same criteria when a company publishes multiple documents.
Selection Reason for inclusion or exclusion and cases in which the document was not available. Define the rules before evaluating the content.

Maintain a record of reviewed, unavailable, and excluded documents, along with the corresponding reason. Excluding a report due to lack of access may be a valid methodological decision if stated; it should not be interpreted as evidence that the company does not disclose sustainability information.

How to review GRI, IFRS and indicators

To compare sustainability reports, it is necessary to identify which standards each company uses, their scope, and the information that supports their application. The GRI standards focus on communicating an organization's impacts on the economy, the environment, and people, while IFRS S1 and S2 address the disclosure of financial information related to sustainability and climate.

It is not enough to find the name of a standard: record the exact statement, the scope it refers to, and the available documentary evidence. If the report does not specify a version or application period, note this as missing information, without inferring it.

Code what each report states

A descriptive code helps compare documents without turning the mention of a standard into a conclusion about compliance. For example, it can distinguish between a mentioned standard, an included index or correspondence table, an explicit statement of use with a described scope, and a standard not found after review. These are analytical labels, not official quality levels or certifications.

Record GRI and IFRS separately when a document refers to both. Note the name and version identified in the report itself, the related sections or indexes, and the entities or periods covered. Do not assume that citing a standard is equivalent to applying it fully, or that the two have interchangeable scopes.

If the analysis includes statements about the validity or technical application of the standards, these must be compared with the official publications corresponding to the evaluated period.

Use a common matrix for the indicators

The following matrix helps capture comparable information. It should only be completed with items that the document presents or that can be verified within it; cells lacking evidence are recorded as not reported or not located, never as a zero value.

Element What to register Careful interpretation
Perimeter and period Entities covered, declared scope and period to which the data correspond. A piece of data is only comparable if its scope is sufficiently defined.
Framework and index Name, indicated version, statement of use and cross-references present. A mention does not prove that the report covers all references in the framework.
Indicator Definition, unit, reported value, covered entity, and period. Do not compare values if the definitions or perimeters differ without explanation.
Methodology Basis of calculation, sources or methodological notes described in the report. Do not reconstruct data or fill gaps with unpublished assumptions.
Goals and evolution Baseline, target, horizon, and progress when reported. Distinguish between a stated goal and an achieved result.
Governance and review Responsibilities or review processes described and scope of any assurance mentioned. Do not infer that a review covers the entire report if the document does not specify this.

Choose the indicators before comparing the results and explain why they are relevant to the research question. For a quantitative comparison to be reasonable, ensure that the definition, unit, period, and scope match. If you make a conversion or adjustment, retain the original data and document the operation; if the datasets are not comparable, it is preferable to present the information separately.

An aggregate maturity score requires pre-established criteria, rules for missing data, and weightings. Without these elements, a descriptive matrix is often more transparent than a general ranking of companies.

How to ensure traceability and communicate boundaries

Traceability allows another person to understand how each observation was obtained and to review its supporting documentation. Maintain a record of evidence associated with each document, code, and indicator. At a minimum, retain:

  1. The original source of the document, its publication date, and the date it was consulted.
  2. The reported period and the version of the reviewed file.
  3. The page, section, or table where the evidence appears.
  4. The applied code and the methodological rule that justifies the decision.
  5. Ambiguities, changes in criteria, and decisions made to resolve them.

A brief coding protocol, tested before being applied to the entire sample, helps different people interpret the criteria consistently. If disagreements arise, record how they were resolved and maintain the final criterion for all comparable documents. The methodology, exclusions, and cutoff date should accompany any subsequent presentation of results.

The analysis also has limitations. Reports may cover different periods, sectors, and scopes; their format and level of detail may vary. Public information does not allow for automatic verification of all data, nor does it replace an independent evaluation. The absence of an indicator may reflect that it was not found in the reviewed documents, not necessarily that the company lacks a related practice. Similarly, any reference to review or assurance must be described according to the scope declared in the report itself. When an organization needs to strengthen confidence in the information disclosed, it can resort to processes of ESG/ASG assurance, always considering the specific scope of the evaluation.

If the benchmark addresses legal or regulatory obligations, these must be analyzed separately and compared with official sources in effect for the relevant period and entity. A public report alone is insufficient to conclude whether a company complies with or fails to comply with an applicable obligation.

How to leverage ESG report comparisons to improve business reporting

A comparison of sustainability reports from Colombian companies is most useful when it applies uniform criteria, documents its sources, and acknowledges the differences between sectors, periods, and methodologies. Its value lies not in determining which organization is more sustainable, but in identifying which information is comparable, which aspects require further explanation, and what the limitations of the analysis are.

For companies, these results can serve as a benchmark for strengthening their disclosure processes, improving the traceability of indicators, and identifying opportunities for improvement. Having clear, consistent, and well-supported ESG information facilitates its evaluation and contributes to more transparent corporate communication.

Frequently Asked Questions

? Where can I find sustainability reports from Colombian companies to compare them?

Reports can be found on corporate websites, in sustainability sections, investor relations departments, and official disclosure repositories. It is advisable to prioritize documents published by the companies themselves, note their date, and keep a copy of the version consulted. If multiple versions exist, identify which one will be used for comparison.

? What to do when two companies present different sustainability indicators?

First, check if the indicators address the same objective and use equivalent definitions, units, and time periods. When methodologies or scopes differ, it is preferable to present the results separately and document the differences. Creating a joint ranking using figures that cannot be directly compared is not recommended.

? How to identify potential inconsistencies in the indicators of an ESG report?

It is helpful to compare the figures with their definitions, units, previous periods, and methodological notes. Significant unexplained changes, discrepancies between tables, or missing information about the scope may require further review. A document inconsistency is a signal to delve deeper into the analysis, not automatic proof of incorrect information.

? When does a company need independent assurance of its sustainability report?

Independent assurance can be beneficial when a company needs to strengthen the confidence of investors, partners, or other stakeholders in the ESG information it discloses, or to address specific verification requirements. This process allows for the evaluation of specific information through specialized procedures, according to the agreed-upon scope. Firms like Amézquita offer ESG/ESG assurance services to support organizations in these types of assessments, without automatically verifying the entire report.

? How can a specialized firm help improve a company's sustainability reports?

A specialized firm can support the definition of indicators, the organization of ESG information, the documentation of methodologies, and the identification of opportunities for improvement in disclosure processes. Amézquita offers sustainability reporting services and support in ESG/ESG strategies, which can help organizations structure clearer, more consistent, and more useful information for their stakeholders.
This article has been verified by
Humberto González,
Public accountant

Search