The responsibilities of an auditor in a condominium association should focus on reviewing resources, financial information, contracts, and controls. Before hiring one, the administration and board should evaluate the auditor's experience, independence, methodology, scope, and the quality of their reports. This guide will help you determine what to look for in a proposal and what indicators will help you decide if the service truly meets the needs of the condominium association.
The contracting process should be based on the real needs of the co-ownership.
A condominium association manages resources for multiple owners, collects ordinary and extraordinary fees, contracts suppliers, performs maintenance, manages accounts receivable, and makes decisions through collective bodies. Therefore, the selection of the auditor should not be based solely on the value of the fees or the professional's availability.
The starting point is to identify which risks, processes, and decisions require further review. Before requesting proposals, management can prepare a basic diagnostic that includes:
- Annual budget and expenditure execution.
- Collection of fees and portfolio level.
- Relevant contracts and works in progress.
- Findings from previous periods.
- Accounting software and main controls.
- Situations that have generated doubts or claims between co-owners.
This information allows for a better understanding of the scope of the project and reduces the risk of receiving generic proposals that later prove insufficient.
The statutory auditor does not replace management, the accountant, the board of directors, or the shareholders' meeting. Their work must remain independent of the activities they will subsequently have to review. For a broader context, please consult [reference to relevant documentation]. What is a tax auditor and what do they do?; This article, however, focuses on how to evaluate service within a co-ownership.
Preliminary questions that the council must resolve
Before inviting candidates, the board should agree on what it expects from the statutory auditor. This is not about demanding absolute oversight of every transaction, but rather about establishing review priorities.
A co-ownership with a large portfolio may require closer attention to collections and reconciliations. If there is a major construction project, the focus may shift to approvals, contracts, advance payments, insurance policies, supporting documentation, and payments.
These questions help to organize the evaluation:
- Which processes have experienced errors, delays, or recurring complaints?
- Are there any contracts, projects, purchases, or lawsuits that require closer monitoring?
- Does the financial information reach the board in a timely manner and allow for informed decision-making?
- Are there any observations from previous periods that are still open?
- Are the budget, its execution, and the cash flow consistent with the operation of the building or complex?
What to review in the experience of the fiscal auditor in horizontal property
The functions of the statutory auditor in horizontal property require understanding not only the financial statements, but also how common resources are managed and documented.
In addition to verifying the relevant professional qualifications, the co-ownership should assess whether the candidate is familiar with processes such as:
- Budgets and administration fees.
- Portfolio of owners or premises.
- Contracts for security, cleaning and maintenance.
- Works and extraordinary fees.
- Reconciliations and payments.
- Minutes and decisions of the administrative bodies.
The administration may request verifiable references, descriptions of comparable assignments, anonymized examples of reports where possible, and profiles of those who will actually participate in the work.
Experience must be demonstrable, not declarative.
A solid proposal should explain how the work will be carried out, how often reviews will be conducted, what documents will be needed, how findings will be communicated, and what the main deliverables will be.
It is advisable to avoid ambiguous expressions such as “the accounts will be reviewed periodically” if it is not clarified what that review means.
The administration needs to know, for example, whether processes such as reconciliations, payments, procurement, accounts receivable, budgeting, supporting documentation, and authorization controls will be included. A specific case study may also be presented during the selection process.
Example: If the complex has a facade project financed through a special assessment, the candidate may be asked how they would review the approvals, budget, supplier selection, contract, insurance policies, progress payments, invoicing, and payments.
A technical and specific response allows for a better assessment of the applicable experience than a generic commercial presentation.
Independence and potential conflicts of interest
Independence is an essential condition for the auditor to be able to communicate observations and conclusions without participating in the activities that he will later have to evaluate.
Therefore, before hiring, it is advisable to check if there are professional, economic or personal relationships that could affect their objectivity or generate a conflict of interest.
It is also important to avoid having the professional simultaneously undertake operational tasks that would require a subsequent review of their own work. This could occur, for example, if they are directly involved in accounting, payment processing, or decisions that will later fall within the scope of the audit.
A useful practice is to request a declaration of independence and conflicts of interest before starting the service.
The administration can also incorporate the following into its evaluation matrix:
- Declared links with members of the co-ownership.
- Additional services offered by the same provider.
- Possible incompatibilities.
- Measures planned to protect independence.
If additional specialized support is required, it is advisable to clearly define each service to avoid duplication and preserve the objectivity of the audit.
Technical scope: what the work proposal should include
The functions of the fiscal auditor in horizontal property become more useful when they become a clear work plan, based on risks and adapted to the size and operation of the co-ownership.
The proposal should allow us to identify:
- Processes that will be within the scope.
- Frequency of reviews.
- Planned procedures or tests.
- Information that the administration must provide.
- Main reports and deliverables.
- Communication and monitoring channels.
A responsible proposal should not promise the absolute detection of errors or fraud. What is important is understanding how the areas of greatest vulnerability will be identified, which controls will be reviewed, and how situations that could affect the co-ownership's resources or information will be communicated.
| Item to be required | Expected evidence | Benefit for co-ownership |
|---|---|---|
| Sectoral experience | References, comparable cases and team profile | Review aligned with horizontal property risks |
| Work plan | Timeline, processes, tests, and deliverables | Clear expectations and timely follow-up |
| Independence | Declaration of conflicts and safeguards | Greater objectivity in observations and recommendations |
| Executive reports | Reports with findings, responsible parties and dates | Decisions better supported by the council |
Processes that normally deserve priority attention
When reviewing the functions of the statutory auditor in horizontal property, the administration must verify that the scope especially includes the processes that concentrate resources, authorizations or greater exposure to errors.
These may include:
- Collections and portfolio.
- Payments to suppliers.
- Bank reconciliations.
- Petty cash management.
- Hiring.
- Budget execution.
- Applicable obligations.
- Conservation of supports.
- Access controls to administrative or accounting systems.
The level of attention will depend on the characteristics of each co-ownership. Not all require the same level of review nor face the same risks.
When the main question is determining in which situations there is an obligation to have this figure, you can consult our content on Who is required to have a tax auditor in Colombia?.
Reports that help in decision-making, not just in filing away
Reports are one of the main means by which the auditor communicates relevant situations to management and the corresponding bodies.
Before hiring, it is advisable to agree on:
- What reports will be issued.
- How often?
- Who will they be aimed at?
- How the findings will be classified.
- How the recommendations will be monitored.
A late, overly technical, or poorly prioritized report may lose its usefulness for decision-makers.
A practical structure may include the issue reviewed, the situation identified, the associated risk, the recommendation, and the follow-up status.
Example: If outstanding discrepancies are detected in bank reconciliations, the report should allow for an understanding of what happened, what its impact may be, and what follow-up action is required.
The usefulness of the report does not depend on its length, but on the fact that the observations are understandable, supported, and can be managed by the relevant authorities.
The relationship with the council should be professional and orderly.
The auditor must be able to engage in dialogue with management and the board without becoming involved in daily operations or internal conflicts.
Therefore, it is advisable to agree from the beginning:
- Communication channels.
- Follow-up meetings.
- Handling of confidential information.
- Procedures for handling relevant alerts.
- How to respond and close comments.
A finding that persists over several periods may indicate that the action taken was insufficient, that it has not yet been implemented, or that the risk remains.
Having a monitoring mechanism helps the board to understand the evolution of these issues without replacing the operational responsibilities of the administration.
Fees, resources and quality of service
Comparing fees is necessary, but selecting only the lowest-priced proposal can mask important differences in dedication, experience, review frequency, or quality of deliverables.
To compare proposals under more equivalent conditions, it is advisable to request information on:
- Estimated hours or dedication.
- Responsible professional.
- Support team.
- Included activities.
- Frequency of reports.
- Expenses or services not included.
The complexity of co-ownership must also be considered. A building with stable operations may require a different scope than a complex with multiple towers, commercial premises, numerous contracts, significant construction projects, or a substantial portfolio.
If the service will be provided by a firm, it is also useful to review its supervisory capacity, team continuity, and contingency support.
When is it advisable to hire specialized support?
Understanding the functions of the statutory auditor in horizontal property also helps to identify when a situation requires an additional scope or a different specialized service.
This can occur in circumstances such as:
- Major changes in administrator or accountant.
- Works of significant value.
- Recurring differences in balances or reconciliations.
- Findings that are not corrected.
- Significant weaknesses in controls.
- Significant changes in accounting or administrative systems.
- Situations that require a specific technical review.
Additional support does not necessarily replace the statutory audit. The important thing is to define the objective beforehand and clearly separate the scope of work to avoid duplication or compromising independence.
Amézquita has a statutory auditing service which can be evaluated by organizations seeking independent technical support in reviewing their financial information, controls, and applicable compliance.
Choosing the right auditor improves the usefulness of the service.
The functions of the fiscal auditor in horizontal property provide greater value when the scope responds to the real risks of the co-ownership and there is clarity on methodology, independence, reports and follow-up.
Management and the board can strengthen the selection process by defining their needs beforehand, comparing proposals under equivalent criteria, and requesting concrete evidence of experience and technical capacity.
The goal is to select a service whose scope is consistent with the operation of the co-ownership and allows for useful information to monitor its resources, controls, and main risks.
Frequently Asked Questions
? What are common mistakes when comparing statutory audit proposals?
One of the most frequent mistakes is to only compare fees without confirming whether the proposals have the same scope, dedication, team, and deliverables.
- Example: Two proposals may have similar values, but one includes periodic reviews and follow-up of findings, while the other only contemplates certain documentary activities.
- Recommendation: Compare experience, independence, methodology, processes included, frequency and reports using a common evaluation matrix.
? What indicators can the council review to assess the usefulness of the service?
Usefulness should not be measured by the length of the reports, but by the timeliness of the observations and the possibility of following up on the issues identified.
- Example: The council may review open findings, recurring issues, commitment dates, and the evolution of actions taken.
- Recommendation: From the outset of the contract, agree on a monitoring mechanism that allows us to know which observations are still pending and which have already been addressed.
? How does accounting software influence the functions of the statutory auditor in horizontal property ownership?
Software can facilitate the traceability of collections, payments, portfolio, budgets and authorizations, but its existence alone does not guarantee that the controls are adequate.
- Example: A platform can correctly record payments and still maintain overly broad permissions to create suppliers or modify sensitive information.
- Recommendation: Inform the auditor what systems the co-ownership uses and how the profiles, accesses and authorizations are distributed so that these elements can be considered within the scope when relevant.
? What should you ask before hiring an auditing firm?
It is advisable to ask who will be responsible for the assignment, what experience the team has, what processes will be included, how often reviews will be carried out, and what reports the management or board will receive.
- Example: If there is a major project, one may specifically ask how the related approvals, contracts, support, and payments will be incorporated into the work.
- Recommendation: request that the relevant answers be reflected in the proposal in order to compare suppliers under equivalent criteria.
? What documentation should the administration prepare before requesting a proposal?
To properly size the service, it is advisable to provide information on the characteristics of the co-ownership, budget, financial statements, portfolio, relevant contracts, works in progress and main situations that require attention.
- Example: If there are recurring findings in reconciliations or payments, reporting them in the quote allows the candidate to better assess the required dedication.
- Recommendation: Prepare an initial summary of risks and critical processes before requesting proposals. This helps ensure that the scope and fees better reflect the actual needs of the co-ownership.
